OUR WORK

How A Cottage in the City Reignited Growth Through Full Funnel Paid Media and Brand Strategy

read case study

29%

Increase in AOV

43%

Increase in Return On Ad Spend

35%

Forecasted Increase in Sessions YoY

10%

Increase in CTR

Overview

A Cottage in the City is a boutique home décor retailer specializing in curated, nostalgic, and emotionally-driven pieces that transform houses into warm, personal sanctuaries. With its roots as a small shop on Long Island, A Cottage in the City has evolved into an online destination known for hand-selected collections that resonate with customers seeking meaning and story in their spaces.

In early 2025, amid a shifting economic landscape and intensifying competition in home furnishings, ACITC partnered with AdVenture Media to build a comprehensive strategic roadmap. The goal: reignite growth by sharpening the brand’s unique positioning, expanding channel strategies, and elevating both traffic and conversion outcomes.

Challenges

Declining Traffic & Rising Acquisition Costs: After peaking in Q4 2024, site traffic began to decline, driven largely by increasing CPCs (Google Ads up ~10% YoY). This meant ACITC was paying more for fewer visits, compressing their acquisition funnel.

Market Saturation & Low Barriers to Entry: The home décor e-commerce space remains fragmented, with rising saturation and new boutique players increasing pressure on customer acquisition and brand differentiation.

Consumer Discretionary Income Tightening: Despite long-term growth projections for the industry, elevated interest rates, tariffs, and inflation were making shoppers more selective, especially with large or discretionary home purchases.

Under-Leveraged Channels: ACITC’s traffic mix was over-reliant on Google (about 40% direct, 25% Google, limited Meta), unlike competitors who used stronger Meta and brand retargeting strategies to build efficient conversion paths.

Missed Cart Opportunities: While add-to-cart rates had been improving, cart-to-checkout conversions dropped, signaling room to optimize bottom-funnel flows and lift total transactions.

Platforms Leveraged

Google Ads: Including Shopping, Performance Max, and Branded Search to capture high-intent buyers.
Meta Ads: Advantage+ Catalog, Lookalike Prospecting, Static Brand Ads, and Retargeting to expand reach and recover abandoners.
Website & Email: Reinforcing brand storytelling, launching bundles, and preparing loyalty/design programs to build repeat business.

Strategies

1. Reinvest in PPC to Drive Traffic

  • Smartly increased spend across Google and Meta with distinct roles: Google captured high-intent traffic, while Meta expanded awareness and recaptured site visitors.
  • Expected to drive a 20-30% increase in sessions by Q4 2025.

2. Launch Meta Prospecting + Retargeting

  • Built Advantage+ Catalog campaigns (7.48 ROAS) and Lookalike audiences (3.74 ROAS) to efficiently reach new audiences and bring them back to purchase.

3. Create Curated Product Bundles to Lift AOV

  • Introduced themed bundles (like “Cottage Kitchen” and seasonal sets) to increase perceived value and transaction sizes by 4-8%, while moving slower SKUs alongside best sellers.

4. Elevate Brand Voice & Visuals

  • Overhauled messaging from generic luxury language to warm, personal, founder-led storytelling. This was rolled out across product pages, ads, and email, positioning ACITC unmistakably as a source of meaningful décor.

5. Prepare Repeat & Designer Programs

  • Updated designer partnership incentives and set groundwork for a loyalty program, both expected to deepen customer lifetime value.

Results

  • Strong ROAS Across Channels: 
  • Meta Advantage+ Catalog campaigns delivered a standout 7.48 ROAS.
  • Google Shopping campaigns drove the highest overall revenue, maintaining a healthy 5.29 ROAS, while combined Google channels achieved a 5.52 ROAS.
  • Total Impact: Over just a few weeks, combined efforts generated ~$52.5K in revenue from ~$10K spend, with a blended ROAS of 5.23 across all platforms.
  • Positive Strategic Indicators:
    • Brand-first static Meta ads had lower volume but delivered a higher AOV of $301 (vs. $233 in product-led campaigns), validating the strategy to cultivate higher-value, emotionally connected buyers.
    • Repeat purchase rates and AOV trends remained steady or slightly improving, setting a foundation for the upcoming loyalty and bundling initiatives.
  • Future Momentum: Based on this trajectory, forecasts show an expected ~35% YoY session growth by Q4 2025, with holiday bundles and loyalty efforts anticipated to further boost conversion volume and efficiency.
  • Higher-Value Buyers: Brand-first campaigns on Meta, though producing fewer purchases, generated significantly higher average order values, affirming the long-term value of building emotional brand connections.

Request A Marketing Proposal

We'll get back to you within a day to schedule a quick strategy call. We can also communicate over email if that's easier for you.

Visit Us

New York
1074 Broadway
Woodmere, NY

Philadelphia
1429 Walnut Street
Philadelphia, PA

Florida
433 Plaza Real
Boca Raton, FL

General Inquiries

info@adventureppc.com
(516) 218-3722

AdVenture Education

Over 300,000 marketers from around the world have leveled up their skillset with AdVenture premium and free resources. Whether you're a CMO or a new student of digital marketing, there's something here for you.

OUR BOOK

We wrote the #1 bestselling book on performance advertising

Named one of the most important advertising books of all time.

buy on amazon
join or die bookjoin or die bookjoin or die book
OUR EVENT

DOLAH '24.
Stream Now
.

Over ten hours of lectures and workshops from our DOLAH Conference, themed: "Marketing Solutions for the AI Revolution"

check out dolah
city scape

The AdVenture Academy

Resources, guides, and courses for digital marketers, CMOs, and students. Brought to you by the agency chosen by Google to train Google's top Premier Partner Agencies.

Bundles & All Access Pass

Over 100 hours of video training and 60+ downloadable resources

Adventure resources imageview bundles →

Downloadable Guides

60+ resources, calculators, and templates to up your game.

adventure academic resourcesview guides →